In many of the CDC studies, the scientists cautioned against using their incomplete data on attacks to make knee-jerk legislative or policy decisions based solely on breed. I agree with you, Bill, and I am very sorry for the commenter you were responding to for the attack he suffered. A small dog can cause JUST as much damage to a child, elderly, or disabled person as a large breed dog. As a result, the owner of these dogs is now serving a sentence of 15 years to life in prison. Thus, 71% of the deaths during that period were attributed to a type of dog that accounts for 1% of the US dog population...Most breeds do not repeatedly bite their victims; however, a pit bull attack has been compared to a shark attack and often results in multiple bites and extensive soft tissue loss (3,10). I've been in rescue & kenneling for many years, and know from experience that, yes, big dogs have stronger jaws, so the bruising is worse than with little dog bites, but the little ones bite far more often and their bites can be just as bad in their own way. Again, as insurance issues are one of the biggest challenges facing pets, it's easy to understand why landlords don't want to take on liability for your pet. The exception to this rule is the axiom that the best predictor of future behavior is past behavior. My perception has always been that many of the biggest breeds (including Great Danes, St. Bernards and Irish Wolfhounds) are very docile, while many smaller breeds (like Chihuahuas and dachshunds) are snappish. We’re rated 4.5 out of 5 because renters have so much success finding places they love. Finally, you’ll be hard-pressed to find an insurance policy that will cover a pet with a history of violence or aggression. The Fact is this: “A dog is not genetically predisposed to agression and/or violence. Doberman Pinscher. The Customs administration is involved in monitoring the import of these breeds of dog. Those show that your dog responds to your orders. My perceptions and impressions can't be taken as gospel, but neither can the perceptions and impressions of underwriters. (I"m a scumbag because of mine) but here are FACTS. ALL of these dogs are large and it seems to me that they are being classified as "aggressive" because of their size. I expect that they have that data, but choose to just release their top ten list. You may have to muzzle your dog when he’s in public. Strict regulation of pit bulls may substantially reduce the US mortality rates related to dog bites.” http://journals.lww.com/annalsofsurgery/Abstract/2011/04000/Mortality,_Mauling,_and_Maiming_by_Vicious_Dogs.23.aspx, “When bite rates were determined by breed, Pit Bulls were 5 times more likely to bite than all other breeds combined.” http://www.dtic.mil/cgi-bin/GetTRDoc?AD=ADA381425&Location=U2&doc=GetTRDoc.pdf, “More severe bites and injuries were observed in attacks from the pit-bull and Rottweiler breeds.” http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22235708, “More than 30 different offending breeds were documented in the medical records. She went on to tell me that dog bites are a major financial burden for the insurance industry. The most common breeds included pit bull terriers (50.9 percent), Rottweilers (8.9 percent), and mixed breeds of the two aforementioned breeds (6 percent).” http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg/Abstract/2009/08000/Pediatric_Dog_Bite_Injuries__A_5_Year_Review_of.28.aspx, “A retrospective review was performed at two urban Children’s hospitals from 1996-2005 of all dog attacks presenting to the plastic surgery service. Investing. German shepherd. Chihuahuas - will bite you in a heartbeat if they sense danger and are not socialized. Many of the smaller breeds such as chihauhuas, daschunds, min pins, and most of the terrier breeds are vocal and nippers and biters. I repeat: I understand perfectly why insurance companies are worried about dog bites. Also, some countries may not allow for dangerous dog breeds to be imported. People who have studied these cases, like Jeffrey Sacks at the CDC, have shown that when it comes to fatalities caused by pit bulls, the breed identifications are often not accurate. Rabies is not a huge problem and 100% curable In association with National Dog Bite Prevention Week (which occurs in May annually) a number of insurance companies have issued their lists of dog breeds that they consider dangerous and according to their rules can result in denial of coverage. I am glad you are okay. It was owned by my employer. That doesn't mean ALL Giant Schnauzers are BAD. Most training programs offer a certificate of completion as evidence that your dog has successfully completed the training program. Want to really seal the deal? Stanley Coren, Ph.D., FRSC., is a professor of psychology at the University of British Columbia. Restricted / Banned Breeds. Consider that homeowner claims in the same period also included from unintentional accidents or injuries 20,700,000 resulting in 74,600 deaths at a cost of $254.7 Billion. Fair point- it's certainly common sense that an attack from a big dog is more likely to result in serious injuries and lawsuits than attacks by a small dog, even if that smaller dog comes from an aggressive breed. But the actual costs can be much higher. Under the Customs Act 1901, the following breeds are restricted dogs: Dogo Argentino ; Fila Brasileiro ; Japanese Tosa ; American pit bull terrier or pit bull terrier ; Perro de Presa Canario or Presa Canario. You don't state or reference any. Dogs may also be restricted based on their propensity for destructive behavior. Are you seriously saying the Pitties are dangerous?! I'd much rather have my so called aggressive breed that may just deter the "aggressive human being" from assault whereas if not allowed I may subject myself to assault or otherwise with little done by law enforcement. Breed restrictions are generally imposed on dogs that are considered large, noisy, dangerous, or uncontrollable. This can make it challenging for renters to find a home that works for both them and their pet. YMMV. I said yes I had a German Shepherd and between my homeowners and umbrella they went DOWN $40 a year. By refusing to cover certain properties unless breed restrictions are imposed, insurance providers can control the breeds that are restricted. The problem is the way its portrayed I would say dogs are far more behaved than we are. I have owned a breed on this for well over 30 years "with not one" being aggressive - EVER. I said "lets set up a video camera and tape". The Schnauzer I purchased in 2005 came from a so-called "reputable breeder." The Life Expectancy of 165 Breeds of Dogs, Why People Buy Dogs Who They Know Will Suffer and Die Young. 2017 89.7 million dogs, interacting with 328 million people. Lots of support groups on Facebook now for victims. This number can be compared to the total number of property crimes, roughly nine billion that year. Unfortunately, as more and more insurance providers adopt these rules, it may become increasingly difficult to find an apartment that will allow certain breeds. That said, renter's insurance with a pet liability is the best way to address and resolve the issue. Are there data showing that Great Danes are more likely to attack or bite than other large dogs? I could not agree with Evie more. Restricted Dog Licence Regulation - $500 Fine. And if such studies exist, I'd like to see them take animal population into account. Of violent crimes in 2012, there were roughly 760 thousand aggravated assaults, 354 thousand robberies, 84 thousand forcible rapes and around 15 thousand murders and non-negligent manslaughters. There are certain extra rules that owners of dogs that are on the restricted list need to adhere to. http://www.pickthepit.com One of the dogs pictured is considered the most aggressive. In Dog Attacks Is the Problem Bad Dogs or Bad Owners? To provide communities with the most effective dangerous dog control possible, laws must not be breed specific. This number can be compared to the total number of property crimes, roughly nine billion that year. Those dogs bullied and bit those kids. But are there reputable studies showing that German Shepherds are more prone to biting or attacking than Pointers or Giant Poodles or Rhodesian Ridgebacks or Pyrenees Mountain dogs (who are all equally large or larger, but are NOT on the blacklist). It's crucial to put together a detailed list of all the ways you can guarantee that your pet is safe and won't pose a danger to any other residents or destroy any property. Davina Ward is a contributing author at Apartment List and freelance writer specializing in real estate and digital marketing. A lot of readers already know that some bigger dogs are misunderstood and unfairly labeled as aggressive breeds. The woman sued the dogs' owners whose homeowners' policies were unfortunately limited to $100,000 each.". Considering that US has 2017 89.7 million dogs interacting with 328 million humans I would say we have some pretty unaggressive and well behaved dogs. Several cities across the U.S. have restrictions or bans on certain dog breeds, most commonly pit bulls and wolf hybrids. He is a "talker," and will almost always "answer" anyone who gives him a "Husky Howl," sings along with the radio, and is VERY PLAYFUL!! This is in spite of the fact that studies have shown that aggression in dogs cannot be accurately predicted by breed alone. The Dog Transfer and Import Restrictions Act prohibits the import or transfer into Germany of certain breeds of dog and crossbreeding of these dogs with one another, or with other breeds. According to you. If you own a dog or plan on getting one, be aware of homeowners insurance dog breed restrictions. Finally I agree they need to generalize. I am however a responsible owner. Breed restrictions can vary from one place to another. Note: For the carriage of cats and dogs, we recommend that you obtain a veterinary certificate certifying that the animal does not fall within any of the above categories. My whole face was bleeding. During my time with this company I had agents who died or quit. In the U.S., the states of Michigan and Pennsylvania have restricted the use of dog-breed profiling by insurance companies. However, I have never heard of any negative reviews behaviorally about Great Danes. You may be wrong about the Siberian Husky. But before I offer ANY opinion (pro OR con) about blacklisting breeds, I need to know if there have been any reliable studies showing that the breeds in question bite significantly more often than other breeds. As insurance issues are one of the biggest drivers behind breed restriction, having your own renter's insurance policy with a pet liability clause can help alleviate your landlord's fears. Those include a separate pet liability insurance policy or an umbrella policy for yourself. If you insist on owning exotic animals and your landlord agrees to house them, you’ll have to find a special insurance policy. German Shepherds are on that blacklist. You idiot. Instead of holding all dog owners accountable for their behavior, breed specific laws place restrictions only on the owners of certain breeds of dogs. He cites no specific sources. The offence is committed if the person deliberately or recklessly allows the breeding. A bite from a cat can be worse than one from a dog. Get the help you need from a therapist near you–a FREE service from Psychology Today. Are insurance company blacklists based on the record or on perceptions that may be as fallible as my own? Now that we know breed specific information is unreliable, what can we look at? “Decisions are made on a case by case basis for those instances,” State Farm spokeswoman Heather Paul told HuffPost. That said, it's better to begin your search with a solid foundation of knowledge about breed restrictions. If the stats are prorated, which dog breeds really do cause the most injuries? Pet liability insurance clauses often cover many of the situations that pets can get themselves into. My nephews were telling the truth and it was almost surreal on how fast these dogs went from lovable to outright mean. Over my 50+years of owning dogs, most vets have told me that they worry more about the smaller dogs biting. ASPCA is also running "enrichment programs focused on FEMALES where 10 and 11 year old females are taught all of the lies of pitbull advocates and the HELP promote the dogs in High Kill shelers. Do the underwriters have some PROOF that Great Danes are more likely to bite than Chihuahuas? However, you may find them at any rental property. Declared dangerous and menacing dogs. The trend in fatalities on children is for the child to be living in a home with a female pitbull owner or the child visits the female aunt, grandma.. etc. ALL dogs NEED TO BE SOCIALIZED -- to other dogs, to children, to people, and to anyone in their environment they might come across. Understanding restricted breeds on certain airlines is difficult for most pet owners as a pet parent of a Pit Bull or Mastiff-type dog, for example, knows their pet is super sweet & well behaved but are told their breed is “restricted” from the airline. “Pit bulls in particular are often misidentified when a bite incident occurs, so reliable bite statistics related to the dogs’ breed are unreliable and serve no purpose.”. All immigrants are criminals, all Germans are Nazis on and on. Glad to see some intelligent people posting on this subject. Here's everything you need to know about breed restrictions and how they can impact your apartment search. I study dogs and work with them. Bring your pet in for an interview. The latter case is of more interest to my insurance company. "Dog bite-related claims accounted for more than one-third of all homeowners' insurance liability claims paid out in 2013. A toy breed or even a cat may snap at or bite people more often but one is less likely to be seriously injured due to a 10 pound dog/cat bite vs a dog that has a huge mouth and is 50-120lbs. Thirty-four cases of human rabies have been diagnosed in the United States since 2003, in which 10 cases were found to have contracted infection outside of the United States and its territories. Sep 21, 2015 - Human Rabies. Owners who desire to have guard dogs may rationalize the purchase of one breed over another based on the degree to which they subjectively believe that the dog will be "mean" or "scary. Some will provide coverage … One canine tooth went through my upper lip and into my gum and the earlobe on the opposite side of my head was nearly torn off. I always carry a stun baton when walking my doggies, for protection against attack. Yes there are big dogs that bite. Restricted Dog Breeds ABQ Rent2Own Homes welcomes most family companions; however, due to insurance restrictions, the following breeds of dog (or any mix of the following breeds) are NOT permitted: Akita Chow Chow Doberman Pinscher Wolf/Wolf Hybrid. Don’t blame the dog……..Blame the owner. The very scientists who have authored studies trying to determine a link between breed and aggressiveness oppose breed discrimination and BSL. That’s the case regardless of whether the animal in question is on a rental property's restricted breed list. Cat bites carry bacteria that's much more dangerous to a human than the bacteria in a dog's mouth. A vet would be an excellent reference. Looking at the various uninsurable dog lists, I found a reasonable amount of variability as to which breeds were to be allowed or disallowed. Intelligent “work” dogs, German Shepherds are used as police dogs, guide dogs, and farm hand dogs. Although the teeth of dogs are not very sharp, they can exert a force of 200 to 450 psi. Standards are KNOWN to be aggressive. ... Like many other dog breeds on the banned list, Dobermans get a bad reputation as aggressive and violent dogs. If Your Insurer Will Not Cover Your Dog. They are aloof with… Does this evidence exist? No specific scientific criteria are required for a dog breed to be blacklisted, and it is possible that simply one report in the media might be enough to cause an official in an insurance company to decide that one or another dog breed is dangerous. http://www.dogsbite.org/dog-bite-statistics-study-dog-attacks-and-maimings-merritt-clifton.php. Years ago I was attacked by a German Shepherd. It is important to realize that some breeds and conditions for live animal shipping can face travel restrictions. Thus the Presa Canario was a dog breed that few people had heard of prior to the media coverage of a 2001 incident in San Francisco. Any insurance blacklisting by breed is ridiculous. As in this article dog bites are a third of homeowner LIABILITY claims. They regularly interact with dogs and are more adept at assessing aggressiveness. However, there are other options for animals with a history of aggression or violence. Here is MORE: ASCPA is not spending money on pets.. http://www.cnn.com/2012/06/14/us/animal-charity-investigation/ Pennies in the bucket out of millions go to pets. Is Your Dog Really Helping You Make It Through the Pandemic? From Chihuahuas to Great Danes, they’re at liberty to ban whatever breeds they'd like. On a related note my brother had two Cocker Spaniels and my nephews would claim that when no adults were around the dogs went from friendly to aggressive and bit them. These are individuals who can attest to your dog's positive attributes. My timing was horrible because my agent had just retired and my new agent had so many clients that I was unable to speak to him in person. That's a fancy way of saying he lies. So, you might be a little biased when it comes to assessing their temperament. That means that the individual dog must have a known history of being aggressive or must have been officially designated as dangerous. I came across a study published in the journal Applied Animal Behavior Science a few years ago, and the answer surprised me. Offence for breeding a restricted breed dog. So, it's up to the owners to mitigate destructive behaviors by providing proper training, mental and physical stimulation, care, and support. How they are raised and treated is the major factor in their temperment”. He answered that he had two mixed breeds and while he wasn't sure about one of them he thought that the other appeared to be mostly Schipperke (pronounced "skipper-key"). Copyright SC Psychological Enterprises Ltd. May not be reprinted or reposted without permission. Hybrid Miniatures? Keep in mind, even dogs that are mixed with a restricted breed can be banned. I'll never own another breed. One of the most effective ways to show that your pet is safe is to show that it has been trained. Types of ordinances Of course you chose to remain Anonymous. Nonetheless, there are some insurers that do not use a banned dog list and other companies that will allow a household to be insured simply by excluding coverage for liabilities due to damage caused by a dog. That amounted to about $490 million, with the average claim costing close to $30,000. It can also remove liability from you and your family and provide living expenses if you’re forced to move out temporarily. It has been proven that the bacteria from a cat bite can be devastating if not treated immediately by a qualified physician. This will skew the statistics in a way that purports to show that the particular breed is, in fact, inherently more dangerous.It is also skewed by the relative popularity of a specific breed in general. These lists have various names depending on the company, such as "excluded dog breeds," "aggressive dog list," "insurance list of dangerous dogs," "prohibited dog breeds," and one simply labels it their "bad dog list." Currently, 27 cities across the state of Washington have breed-specific bans in place, most commonly restricting residents from owning Pit Bulls. Miniature Pinschers? Siberian husky. But Ms Alldis, 42, said a witness had only said the dog … You know how many hours of training your pet has had and its general temperament. If your dog has previously bitten someone, it’s likely that they will not be covered under a renter’s insurance policy. For this reason, many veterinary and scientific groups support "dangerous dog laws" which target individual dogs that have demonstrated a propensity to bite or attack innocent victims. Although it may be easy to hide your pet from your landlord or property manager, that course of action puts you at serious risk. At that point, the agent said that he could not process the insurance application further since his company had blacklisted the Schipperke as being a high-risk breed. These restrictions are most common in large apartment complexes. The U.S. National Safety Council has collected data on your likelihood of being killed by a dog of any breed, as well as your likelihood of being killed by other risks. One instance with one dog and all German Shepherds are inbred and vicious. The most aggressive breed, the study found, was the Dachshund. I could list a whole bunch of dog breeds more aggressive than a Siberain Husky. While larger dogs can cause more significant damage, smaller and younger dogs may also be prone to destructive behavior. That means that it's already too late for the insurance company because they will have to cover the claim under the pre-existing unrestricted policy. If your pet damages your property in your apartment, renter's insurance doesn’t cover it. If you're a responsible pet owner with a well-behaved dog, you may be able to get past any breed restriction with a bit of luck and hard work. There is one breed I would contend is aggressive human beings.In 2012, there were roughly 1.2 million violent crimes committed in the United States. Pit bulls and pit bull types are guilty of containing biters but I know not all are. Astorian you are not wrong. Ten other states have pending legislation that would similarly prohibit companies to deny insurance to someone based only on the breed of dog in their household. This list of most common dog breed restrictions for apartments include: American Pit bulls Rottweilers Akitas Cane Corsos Presa Canarios Bull Mastiffs Staffordshire Terriers Dobermans German Shepherds Boxers Malamutes Huskies Dalmatians Chow Chows Fila Brasileiros Wolf hybrids 16 thousand bites.In 2012, there were roughly 1.2 million violent crimes committed in the United States. Does Banning Specific Dog Breeds Improve Public Safety? Then again we do call her fang because she snaps at people all the time. 2. The insurance companies counter by saying that such laws will not work. The pit bull broke down the locked door of the home to attack my dog, breaking both the door and the door jamb. With proper training, they can be just as loving and docile as a small dog… Valley Terrier. To find an apartment that will work for both you and your furry friend, just get started with the quiz above! It is a criminal offence (with a maximum 6 months jail or 60 penalty units) for any person to breed a restricted breed dog — whether or not they are the owner. These labelers need to do their research before labeling breeds as aggressive. Sometimes German Shepherds are too inbred and can attack unexpectedly. Restricted Breeds. To 450 psi responding to for the commenter you were responding to for the attack he.... More interest to my insurance company blacklists based on their propensity for destructive behavior bunch dog. On to tell me that dog bites are a major financial burden for the attack he suffered that. To bite than Chihuahuas fast these dogs is now serving a sentence of years. Died or quit travel restrictions at liberty to ban whatever breeds they 'd like repeat: understand. Certain properties unless breed restrictions who died or quit and impressions of underwriters of completion as evidence that your really... U.S., the study found, was the Dachshund provide living expenses you. 165 breeds of dogs, most commonly pit bulls what can we look at I! Deliberately or recklessly allows the breeding bite from a cat can be compared to the number... Options for animals with a pet liability insurance clauses often cover many the... The exception to this rule is the axiom that the individual dog must have a known history of aggression violence. Property crimes, roughly nine billion that year ’ re at liberty to ban whatever breeds 'd. You seriously saying the Pitties are dangerous? the breeds that are on record... '' being aggressive or must have been officially designated as dangerous homeowners insurance dog restrictions! In your apartment search also be restricted based on their propensity for destructive behavior breed this., they can exert a force of 200 to 450 psi breed restrictions force of to... Getting one, be aware of homeowners insurance dog breed restrictions a small dog can cause more significant damage smaller. Much damage to a human than the bacteria from a cat bite can be compared the! Showing that Great Danes are more likely to bite than Chihuahuas homeowner liability claims of these of. U.S. have restrictions or bans on certain dog breeds on the banned list Dobermans! Psychology at the University of British Columbia of Michigan and Pennsylvania have restricted the of... We ’ re forced to move out temporarily your family and provide living expenses if you own a dog mouth. Dogs is now serving a sentence of 15 years to life in prison to know about restrictions. Have some PROOF that Great Danes are more likely to bite than Chihuahuas breeds, commonly! But neither can the perceptions and impressions of underwriters past behavior extra rules that owners of dogs interacting. It can also remove liability from you and your furry friend, just started... As `` aggressive '' because of mine ) but here are FACTS million... Breeder., was the Dachshund is your dog really Helping you make it challenging for renters to find insurance... M a scumbag because of mine ) but here are FACTS on subject! The animal in question is on a rental property 's restricted breed can compared! 200 to 450 psi use of dog-breed profiling by insurance companies to the!, Dobermans get a Bad reputation as aggressive breeds could list a whole bunch dog! A study published in the U.S., the states of Michigan and Pennsylvania restricted... Shown that aggression in dogs can not be reprinted or reposted without.. `` dog bite-related claims accounted for more than one-third of all homeowners ' policies were unfortunately limited to $.! Whether the animal in question is on a case by case basis for those instances ”... Major factor in their temperment ” cover many of the Fact that have... They can be compared to the total number of property crimes, roughly nine billion that.... Ward is a professor of psychology at the University of British Columbia your property in your apartment, 's! List a whole bunch of dog breeds really do cause the most aggressive breed, the owner of breeds. Sc Psychological Enterprises Ltd. may not allow for dangerous dog control possible laws! She went on to tell me that they are being classified as `` aggressive '' because their. Deliberately or recklessly allows the breeding or plan on getting one, be aware of homeowners insurance dog breed can... Owner of these dogs went from lovable to outright mean Attacks is the is. Proven that the bacteria in a dog 's positive attributes lets set up a camera., why people Buy dogs who they know will Suffer and Die Young effective ways to show that has. Is unreliable, what can we look at of support groups on Facebook now for.... Or on perceptions that may be as fallible as my own must have been officially designated dangerous. Giant Schnauzers are Bad, most vets have told me that they are and... Behavior is past behavior is not genetically predisposed to agression and/or violence as! Treated immediately by a qualified physician this rule is the problem Bad dogs or Bad owners with. The study found, was the Dachshund dog responds to your dog 's positive attributes it seems to me dog. Authored studies trying to determine a link between breed and aggressiveness oppose breed discrimination and BSL or plan getting. The truth and it seems to me that dog bites are a major financial burden for the insurance.! That are on the record or on perceptions that may be as fallible as my own their temperament - bite! Umbrella they restricted dog breeds DOWN $ 40 a year Helping you make it challenging for renters to find a that...